07/03/2026
Things have gotten pretty bad if Karl Rove is a voice to amplify. He rightly and accurately calls out JD Vance for promoting an Un-American notion of “Heritage Americans”.
The op-ed, comes on the heels of the Supreme court’s ruling on birthright citizenship (a ruling that should’ve been unanimous), making it clear, once again, that the founding documents do not support the bigotry of the president, vice-president, turning point, and the white nationalist MAGA church.
Rove points to our origins and formative decades, of a country that inspired the Emma Lazarus sonnet inscribed at the base of the beacon for the world; give us your tired, your poor, your wretched refuse. The only rule, “abide by the principles of declaration and the constitution written to secure them”.
This is what vitriolic hate mongers like Tom Emmer get wrong. This country never espoused assimilation. We took great effort to not establish an official language, religion, or cultural bias. Diversity is our identity.
Nothing and no one is served by homogeneity, except perhaps the factory floor, where business would prefer automatons over people. That temple of the golden crypto calf, where the worship of gilded excess is practice, and self over country is scripture; that is where our humanity dies and births a perverted notion of being an American.
The country was not perfect in is creation. The Op-ed a little rosy. The 250 years, full of terrible moments and also of inspiring triumphs. If we zoom in on the moment, we might see a country that is losing its way, but if we zoom out a little, we see a trajectory that is undeniably positive.
There will always be preachers of punching down, who want to “throw a sheet over the statue of liberty”, to whiten up and revive the southern cross. They challenge us to remember what America was conceived as, and what millions have fought for. They challenge us to not be complacent in the ongoing work. They challenge us to not give up on this place, despite it’s flaws and failures.
While DC fails us, the people of Minneapolis and Minnesota showed the country what it means to stand up for your neighbor. While DC erected monuments to itself, Chicago built a center of community, hope, and change. America’s proof of life.
This July 4th, consider turning off the news. Step away from your media silo. Connect with your neighbors, find common ground with those who don’t look like you, or speak your language, or pray to your god. Remember what it means to be an American. The idea is the real heritage.
[Karl Rove - WSJ - Heritage Americans; an un-american idea]