09/07/2026
How to vet a roofing contractor after a storm.
Slow down. The roof will still be there next week, and the contractors worth hiring don't pressure you to decide today.
Verify they're real and local. A physical address you can drive to. A phone number that gets answered. Years in business under the same name. Recent local jobs you can actually go look at.
Verify insurance. Current certificates of general liability AND workers' compensation, sent directly from their agent. If an uninsured worker gets hurt on your property, that risk can land on you.
Check the paper trail. Illinois Attorney General consumer complaints, BBB, online reviews. One bad review means little. A pattern means a lot.
Look for claims experience. A contractor who works storm claims can read the adjuster's estimate, meet the adjuster on site, and document supplements properly.
Compare on more than price. On an insurance job the price is largely set by the approved scope β compare materials, warranty, crew, and communication.
Storm-chaser red flags: same-day pressure to sign, any offer to cover your deductible, no verifiable address, an "inspection authorization" that's really a contract, a big cash deposit up front.
How Illinois homeowners can vet a roofing or siding contractor, spot storm-chaser red flags, understand contingency agreements, deposits, deductibles, and warranties.