06/08/2026
"The Boys Plot" at St. James-on-the-Lines Anglican Church
âIt helps the community look better and it brings people together,â says member of St. James on-the-Lines Anglican Church celebrating its 190th anniversary this year
The communityâs green thumbs are helping to commemorate a special part of Penetanguishene history this spring.
Established in the townâs early settlement years, parishioners are celebrating the 190th anniversary of St. James on-the-Lines Anglican Church.
As a way to acknowledge the people who built the town and shaped its character, a childrenâs memorial garden will be planted at what is known as âthe boys plot.â
âWe thought, wouldnât it be nice to have a bigger spot where we can just open it up and be remembering children in general, not jus the boys in that plot,â says Doris Shirriff, Penetanguishene native and member of St. James.
The boys buried on the plot are from The Boys Reformatory of Upper Canada. This institution was established in 1859 where military barracks once stood. It is now the Waypoint Centre for Mental Health Care.
Until 1910, in an effort to separate them from hardened criminals, unruly boys were sent to the reformatory as opposed to adult prisons such as the Kingston Penitentiary. They were put to work, often taking care of the structures that housed them.
The connection between the health centre and the church is still strong today.
Reverend Vickie Edgeworth-Pitcher, the parishâs interim priest since September, noticed that âthe boys made the iron work thatâs on the front doors of the church.â
Later in the reform program they were allowed to attend church in town.
Both Catholic and Protestant churches in Penetanguishene date back to the 1830s, notes Shirriff.
The boys plot was initiated by the government of Ontario around 1910. St. James on-the-Lines has the names of about eight boys from the reformatory at rest there.
However, research revealed that there are about 300 children throughout the cemetery, says Shirriff. Not all their names are known.
Edgeworth-Pitcher reached out to the Penetanguishene Garden Club about the memorial project earlier this year.
Soon after, planning the garden unearthed a broader sense of community spirit and an appreciation for the people of an era long past.
âThey decided on the heart shape, which is just beautiful, and the participants from the Waypoint Mental Health Centre actually prepared the garden for planting, they edged it and dug up the dirt for us,â says Edgeworth-Pitcher.
Deanne Irwin, Penetanguishene Garden Club president, believed right away that this was an appropriate project for them. Her fellow board members agreed.
âIt helps the community look better and it brings people together,â says Irwin.
The heart-shaped garden is meant to instill visitors with love and compassion.
âIt was hard in those days, but people still made the commitment to live and to work and to bring up families,â says Shirriff, acknowledging the grief of burying children.
âWe thought this is a memory, a story that needs to be told.â
As a not-for-profit, the Penetanguishene Garden Club receives grants from the township as well as the Ontario Horticultural Association. Those funds will purchase the plants and supplies to create the childrenâs memorial garden along with other projects this spring.
âI think weâre going to go mostly with perennials, so that they will come up each year, maybe some grasses and hostas,â says Irwin.
Depending on what is available at the garden centres, she hopes to find various flowers that bloom in pinks and reds for the children's garden.
The Penetanguishene Garden Club completes about three community projects every year. Planting 700 red and white tulips at the Cenotaph on Main Street is one of them.
The Penetanguishene Garden Club plans to complete the childrenâs memorial garden by mid-June. Volunteers and new members of all ages are welcome. Find more information here.
St. James on-the-Lines Anglican Church is located at 215 Church St. in Penetanguishene.
Full story and photos in Midland Today
'Story needs to be told': Local memorial garden unearths appreciation for local history
Danielle Pitman - story and photos
Jun 6, 2026 2:30 PM